Puberty 2 Song Sorter
Rank your favorite songs from Mitski's Puberty 2. Choose between two options at a time to build your ultimate personal ranking. Note: This is a filtered view of the full discography.
About Puberty 2
Is Your Best American Girl the best song of the 2010s? Pitchfork put it seventh on its list of the 200 best of the decade, and Rolling Stone had it 13th on theirs, so you're in good company arguing about it. It's about wanting a relationship when her racial identity and upbringing stand in the way, it was the lead single from March 2016, and it got Best New Track from Pitchfork.
She told Stereogum she'd felt out of touch with music after Bury Me at Makeout Creek, so she went back to her roots and drew on all three earlier albums. It was recorded in about two weeks at Acme Studios in Westchester, New York, with Hyland producing, and came out in June 2016, her first on Dead Oceans. Happy was the second single, and A Burning Hill closes it at 1:49. Metacritic has it at 87, Pitchfork gave it an 8.5, and Time had it third on its albums of the year.
The 10th anniversary edition arrived on June 9, 2026, with two covers: One Direction's Fireproof and Frank Sinatra's I'm a Fool to Want You. Those are off by default, so the 11 main tracks are the original album, and you can switch the covers on in Filters.
About two minutes to sort, and Once More to See You gets harder every time I do it. Up next: Be the Cowboy.
About this sorter
- Songs
- 13
- Of the full Mitski sorter
- 14%
- Picks at most
- 29
- To rank, at about 5 seconds a pick
- ~2 min
It's the 2nd largest of the 8 Mitski albums and EPs here. Besides its 11 main tracks, it has 2 under Covers.
"Fireproof" and "I'm a Fool to Want You" are left out by default. You can add them in Filters. The numbers above are for the other 11.
Once you're done, you might enjoy seeing where these songs land among all 92 in the full Mitski sorter.
Songs by type
Puberty 2 Tracklist
Puberty 2
- Happy
- Dan the Dancer
- Once More to See You
- Fireworks
- Your Best American Girl
- I Bet on Losing Dogs
- My Body's Made of Crushed Little Stars
- Thursday Girl
- A Loving Feeling
- Crack Baby
- A Burning Hill
- Fireproof
- I'm a Fool to Want You