Ethel Cain Song Sorter

Choose your favorite song between two options. Your choices will be used to create a personalized ranking of all songs. Note: Neutral choices may reduce accuracy. Your progress saves automatically.

About Ethel Cain

Ethel Cain's Preacher’s Daughter spent almost three years as a cult favorite before the vinyl finally put it in the Billboard 200 top ten in April 2025, making her the first openly trans artist with a US top ten album. Then Willoughby Tucker, I'll Always Love You dropped that August as a prequel and sent everyone back into the lore. Add an eight-minute single and a 75-minute debut, and nobody does an era quite like this.

The sorter has her three EPs, Preacher’s Daughter, Perverts and Willoughby Tucker, I'll Always Love You, plus her American Football cover, For Sure. With the default filters it takes about 19 minutes, and it saves after every pick.

Some of these songs are very long. To ease in, start with Inbred or Golden Age, which take about a minute each, or go straight to Preacher’s Daughter. Her features on other people's songs, Famous Last Words and Aging Young Women, are switched off by default. Turn them on under Features in Filters, or rank them on their own in Collaborations.

One tip. Go easy on the neutral button. Every neutral pick makes your ranking a little less accurate, and there's an undo button if you change your mind.

About this Ethel Cain sorter

Songs: 51
Albums and EPs: 6
Picks at most: 231
To rank, at about 5 seconds a pick: ~19 min

Albums here range from Carpet Bed (4 songs) to Preacher’s Daughter (13 songs). There are also 3 songs from outside the albums, mostly under Features in Filters.

"Famous Last Words (An Ode to Eaters) (1017 ALYX 9SM & Ethel Cain)" and "Aging Young Women (Anna von Hausswolff feat. Ethel Cain)" are left out by default. You can add them in Filters. The numbers above are for the other 49.

Your progress saves after every pick, so you can take a break whenever you like.

For something quicker, Preacher’s Daughter takes about 3 minutes on its own, and every other album has its own page too.